Father Blackwood

Ask the Apostate

How do I get more willpower?

The short answer Willpower isn’t a muscle you bulk up until you can white-knuckle anything—treat it that way and you become the person who’s rigid until they snap. It’s more like the damper on a fire: not a wall against your wants, but a small adjustment to how much air you let them, felt and corrected a little at a time. Wall the fire off and you smother it; throw the doors open and it roars and burns out. The goal was never to want nothing. It was to find the setting where you burn clean.

The longer answer

An old stove or an open hearth is not controlled by force. There’s no wrestling it. What you have is a damper—a small vent, a flap, a lever—that governs one thing only: how much air reaches the fire. And nearly everything the fire does is decided there, by that one small adjustment, read off the heat on your face and the sound of the draw. Open the damper wide and the fire roars up, bright and fast and greedy, and burns through its fuel in an hour and dies. Close it right down and the fire, starved, sulks and smokes and smothers itself into a black choking mess. Neither is control. Both are what happens when you stop tending the damper.

The fire that lasts, and throws steady heat all evening, is held between those—by a damper set not to no air and not to all air, but to the particular narrow opening where the fuel burns clean and complete. And you find that setting by feel, and you keep finding it, because it drifts: more air as the fire catches, less as it settles, a small correction now and then, all night, by someone paying a little attention.

I think willpower is the damper, not the wall—and almost everyone is taught the wall. We’re told it’s a muscle: grit the teeth, deny yourself, throttle the want into submission, and the harder your grip the finer your character. But shut the damper hard against every appetite and you don’t get a virtuous fire; you get a smothered one—the rigid, joyless, brittle person holding everything down by force, who will, at some point, either snap or go cold. Denial isn’t control any more than flinging the doors open is. It’s just the other way of not tending the fire.

The real thing is quieter and never finished: a small adjustment to how much you feed a want, made by feel, corrected as it drifts. Not no and not all, but the narrow setting where the thing burns clean—where you can have the fire and the warmth and the long evening, because you neither starved it nor let it eat everything and gutter out. Self-control is that hand on the damper. It was never about wanting nothing. It was about learning to burn well.

Whether anyone finds the setting for good, I doubt—the fire drifts, and so do we, and the tending doesn’t end. But the damper is the right instrument, and the wall never was. It may be so. It may not.